It's hard to think of an area of rabbonus that carries more weight than sitting with a couple who believe they've reached the point of needing to explore divorce. In that room, a rav often feels a flood of conflicting emotions: Did I do enough as their rav? Did I convey the Torah values that build healthy families clearly enough? Did I miss something? Was there a way to help them that I didn't find? These reactions are completely normal and reflective of the achrayus the rav holds in these scenarios. This is a genuine achrayus, a weight of responsibility similar to what's carried in matters of health and life, because real lives and lasting consequences are at stake.
Points to Keep in Mind
There are three ideas worth holding onto in these moments.
The first is that if a rav listens carefully, stays attentive to the details a couple shares, and consults with those who bring greater experience, wisdom, and knowledge to a given situation, there's real reason for confidence. Guidance built in an attentive, humble manner, and informed by others' expertise, can be trusted to genuinely serve the couple's best interest, even when the outcome remains uncertain.
The second is remembering where the core of the role actually lies. A rav's primary task in these situations is to support the people in front of him, and that is something rabbanim already know how to do well. There may be anxiety about the specific directional questions: should this couple divorce or not, is more counseling needed or less, which Beis Din or mediator should be involved. But none of that uncertainty should overshadow the part of the work that carries no such anxiety at all: the fundamental skill of helping people move through pain and struggle toward a place of wholeness, while helping preserve their relationship with themselves, with Hashem, and with their community. That piece of the responsibility deserves just as much attention as the harder decisions.
The third is trusting in siyata dishmaya. You being placed in that specific room, with that specific couple, is not incidental. Hashem didn't send them to a different rav, and didn't send you to a different community. If someone entered rabbonus for the right reasons, is putting in genuine effort, isn't driven by ego or by keeping score of which families "succeed" and which "fail," and is sincerely asking for the insight to do right by the people in front of him, then his hishtadlus invites siyata dishmaya.
Information Tailored to Your Role
Understand your options and take control of the process.
